Findymail vs LeadMagic
Both start at $99 a month. Findymail's Starter gives 5,000 finder credits plus 5,000 verifier credits. LeadMagic's Essential gives 5,000 credits, and a validation costs 0.25 credits, so up to 20,000 validations. For validation volume LeadMagic goes further per dollar; for finding, Findymail adds its verifier credits on top.
Prices read from findymail.com and leadmagic.io. We sell a competing product, and it is not in the verdict above — where we fit is at the bottom.
| Findymail | LeadMagic | |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest route | $99/mo | $99/mo |
| Per year, if subscribed | $1,188 | $990 |
| Metering | 5,000 verifier credits/mo; rollover up to 2x | 5,000 credits/mo from $99; a validation costs 0.25 credits |
| Credits expire | Allowance resets monthly | Allowance resets monthly |
| Product type | Finder + verifier | Finder + verifier |
| Price checked | 2026-10-12 | 2026-10-12 |
Cost for one pass over a list
Each vendor’s cheapest available route. An empty cell means that vendor does not publish an allowance we can calculate from, not that it is free.
| List size | Findymail | LeadMagic | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,000 | $99.00 | $99.00 | Equal |
| 10,000 | — | $99.00 | Not comparable |
| 50,000 | — | $249.00 | Not comparable |
| 100,000 | — | $495.00 | Not comparable |
How each one bills you
Findymail charges $99 a month for 5,000 verifications, metered as 5,000 verifier credits/mo; rollover up to 2x. LeadMagic charges $99 a month for 20,000 verifications, or $990 for a year, metered as 5,000 credits/mo from $99; a validation costs 0.25 credits.
Findymail's allowance is tied to the subscription period. LeadMagic's allowance is tied to the subscription period. For uneven volume, expiry often matters more than the headline price, because credits that lapse raise the real cost of every address you did verify.
What to watch with Findymail: rollover is capped at twice the monthly allowance, so a quiet quarter loses credits. With LeadMagic: rollover on monthly plans is capped at two months, and annual credits refresh yearly without rolling over.
Both meter verifications, so checking the same list again costs again. Before committing to either, verify an address you invented at a real domain and an address at a catch-all domain on both. The first should come back invalid and the second as risky or accept-all, not valid.
Choose Findymail if
finding addresses is the main job and you want separate verifier credits.
Choose LeadMagic if
you validate more than you find and want the credits to stretch further.
Disclosure — our product
Where SimpleVerifier fits, and where it does not
We publish this comparison and we sell a third option, so treat the rest of this section as the pitch it is. SimpleVerifier is a flat monthly price with unlimited email verifications and API access included, so there are no credits to buy or expire:
Pro $29.99/mo
Unlimited email verification, finder and phone format checks.
Email + Phone $49.99/mo
Everything in Pro, plus live carrier lookups for your phone lists.
That is worth it in two cases: large lists, because volume does not change the price, and lists you verify repeatedly, because a confirmed result is cached for 14 days so the second pass costs nothing. Outside those two cases, a metered vendor is usually cheaper and you should use one, Findymail and LeadMagic included.
Common questions
- Findymail or LeadMagic — which is better?
- Both start at $99 a month. Findymail's Starter gives 5,000 finder credits plus 5,000 verifier credits. LeadMagic's Essential gives 5,000 credits, and a validation costs 0.25 credits, so up to 20,000 validations. For validation volume LeadMagic goes further per dollar; for finding, Findymail adds its verifier credits on top.
- How much do Findymail and LeadMagic cost?
- Findymail costs $99 a month for 5,000 verifications. LeadMagic costs $99 a month for 20,000 verifications, or $990 for a year. Both read from their own pricing pages — Findymail on 2026-10-12, LeadMagic on 2026-10-12.
- Should I choose Findymail?
- Choose Findymail if finding addresses is the main job and you want separate verifier credits.
- Should I choose LeadMagic?
- Choose LeadMagic if you validate more than you find and want the credits to stretch further.
- Is there an alternative to both Findymail and LeadMagic?
- SimpleVerifier is a flat monthly plan rather than credits: Pro at $29.99 a month or Email + Phone at $49.99 a month, with unlimited email verifications and API access included. It suits large lists and lists you re-check often. For a small one-off clean, a metered vendor such as Findymail or LeadMagic can cost less.